Wiser Tricks is an independent financial comparison platform. We may earn a commission when you click through.
Car Finance Compared: Cheapest Rates to Bad-Credit Deals
Compare seven UK car finance providers by APR, credit access, deal type and application speed before choosing HP or PCP.
Quick Picks
Best overall: Zuto Car Finance.
Best budget: Black Horse Car Finance.
Best for bad credit: Moneybarn Car Finance.
Car finance rates begin at 4.9% APR in this comparison, but the advertised starting rate is not the price most borrowers will pay. Zuto’s representative APR is 18.8%, while Moneybarn’s is 30.7% — a reminder that your credit profile matters more than the headline number.
Rates and terms shown are representative. Your actual rate depends on your credit profile and circumstances. This is not financial advice — always read the lender's terms before applying.
Best for comparing dealers and mainstream finance
The cheapest advertised rate is not automatically the cheapest agreement. These four providers cover the mainstream market, but they differ sharply in how you apply and how much choice you get.
Zuto Car Finance
Zuto is my first stop for most buyers because it compares multiple lenders rather than tying you to one finance company. Its rates start at 8.9% APR, but the representative APR is 18.8%, so treat the lower figure as an entry point, not a promise. The 60-second decision uses a soft search, which helps you shop around without immediately adding a hard search to your credit file. You can also browse thousands of dealer cars through the platform. The limitation is important: Zuto is a broker, not a lender, and dealer cars only means private-sale vehicles are excluded. Best for drivers with fair-to-good credit who want several HP or PCP quotes in one application rather than negotiating separately at every dealership.
Zuto Car Finance
CarFinance 247
CarFinance 247 starts at the same 8.9% APR as Zuto, but its representative APR is higher at 19.5%. That difference matters because representative APR is closer to the rate many accepted applicants may see than the tempting starting figure. The site asks for your monthly budget, which can be useful if you need to work backwards from an affordable payment rather than start with a car price. It is still a credit broker, not a direct lender, so the final offer depends on the lenders in its panel and your circumstances. Compared with Zuto, it offers less published detail in the supplied information, including no stated approval time or clear dealer-network size. Best for a borrower who knows the monthly payment they can manage and wants a broker-led quote, but who is prepared to compare the final agreement carefully.
CarFinance 247
Black Horse Car Finance
Black Horse has the lowest advertised rate here at 4.9% APR and sits within Lloyds Banking Group, which may reassure buyers who prefer a large established finance provider. It supports both PCP and HP for new and used cars and is available through many UK dealerships. The catch is access: you cannot apply directly in the same way as with a broker. The dealer presents the finance, and the rate can depend on the relationship and deal structure. A 4.9% starting rate may therefore be less useful than a higher rate from a broker if the latter gives you a cheaper vehicle or better deposit terms. Best for a buyer with good credit who is already at a dealership and wants to compare the dealer’s PCP or HP quote against an outside offer before signing.
Black Horse Car Finance
Close Brothers Motor Finance
Close Brothers Motor Finance brings more than 150 years of lending history and a broad dealer and broker network, with HP and PCP available for new and used cars. Its quoted price in the comparison is 5.9%, but the supplied information does not identify that figure as a representative APR, so do not compare it directly with Black Horse’s 4.9% without checking the actual offer. The lender is available through intermediaries rather than direct consumer applications, and dealer margin can affect the deal you see. That makes the monthly payment, total amount payable and optional final payment more useful than the headline rate alone. Best for buyers who want an established lender through a reputable dealership and are comfortable asking the dealer to show the full cost of the agreement.
Zuto and CarFinance 247 give you more room to compare before choosing a vehicle. Black Horse and Close Brothers are more dealership-led, so the finance conversation happens alongside the car negotiation. Before accepting any quote, ask for the total amount payable, not just the monthly payment. PCP can look cheaper each month because part of the car’s value is deferred to the optional final payment.
For published details, compare the figures with the Zuto car finance page and the Black Horse car finance page. Both are providers’ own descriptions, so use them as a starting point and read the formal credit agreement for the binding terms.
Used-car finance and faster online decisions
Used-car buyers often need a different balance: quick eligibility checks, access to older vehicles and a lender willing to look beyond a thin credit file. The two picks below focus more heavily on that route.
Oodle Car Finance
Oodle focuses on used cars and offers a soft credit check, a quick online process and no deposit required. Its quoted rate is 7.9%, although the supplied data does not label that figure as a representative APR, so ask for the total cost before comparing it with lenders that publish representative figures. The 4.7 Trustpilot rating from 21,395 reviews is the strongest review evidence in this list, but customer ratings cannot tell you whether your own rate will be affordable. Oodle offers HP only, meaning you own the vehicle after the final payment; there is no PCP option with a lower monthly payment and balloon payment. Best for a used-car buyer who values an online decision and wants to avoid an initial deposit, provided the vehicle and final agreement meet the budget.
Oodle Car Finance
MotoNovo Finance
MotoNovo quotes rates from 5.9% APR and supports both HP and PCP across new and used cars. Its network of more than 4,000 dealerships gives it broad reach, but that convenience comes with the same limitation as other dealer-only lenders: direct applications are not available, and your rate depends on your credit profile and the dealer route. The supplied page currently returns a 404, so verify the current product details before relying on the advertised terms. Compared with Oodle, MotoNovo gives you PCP as well as HP and may be easier to find at a local dealership; compared with Zuto, it gives you less ability to compare lenders independently. Best for a used-car buyer who wants HP or PCP through a dealer and can check the full agreement rather than relying on the starting APR.
Online speed is useful, but it should not rush the decision. A soft search can show eligibility without the same immediate credit impact as a hard application, yet the finance agreement still creates a long-term monthly commitment. Check the car’s price, deposit, interest, fees, mileage limits and settlement terms together.
Moneybarn is the outlier because it targets borrowers mainstream lenders may decline. That makes it relevant for a narrower audience, but the cost needs a much harder look.
When poor credit changes the maths
A specialist lender can open the door to HP finance, but access is not the same as affordability. Moneybarn’s representative APR is 30.7%, and its poorest-credit rates can reach 69.9% APR according to the supplied product information.
Moneybarn Car Finance for Poor Credit
Moneybarn is the clearest bad-credit pick here, accepting poor or limited credit for vehicles priced from £3,000 to £25,000. The price of that access is substantial: representative APR is 30.7%, with rates up to 69.9% APR for the weakest profiles. It offers HP only, so there is no PCP structure to reduce the monthly payment by leaving a final balloon amount. That can be easier to understand, but the monthly cost may be higher. Dealer-only availability also means you cannot arrange the entire purchase independently online. Best for a borrower with a poor or limited credit history who genuinely needs a vehicle, has checked the total amount payable and has ruled out waiting, saving a larger deposit or using a cheaper alternative. It should not be the first quote for someone with good credit.
Moneybarn Car Finance for Poor Credit
Comparison table
| Provider | Advertised rate | Finance type | Access | Best for |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Zuto | From 8.9%; representative 18.8% | HP and PCP | Broker, soft decision in 60 seconds | Comparing multiple lenders |
| CarFinance 247 | From 8.9%; representative 19.5% | Not specified in supplied data | Broker; quote based on monthly budget | Budget-led applications |
| Moneybarn | Representative 30.7%; up to 69.9% | HP | Specialist dealer network | Poor or limited credit |
| Close Brothers | Quoted 5.9% | HP and PCP | Dealer and broker intermediaries | Established dealer finance |
| Black Horse | From 4.9% | HP and PCP | Dealership only | Good-credit dealer buyers |
| MotoNovo | From 5.9% APR | HP and PCP | More than 4,000 dealerships | Used-car dealer finance |
| Oodle | Quoted 7.9% | HP | Online soft-check process | Quick used-car decisions |
For the latest terms, review the Moneybarn car finance page and compare its formal offer with the broker and dealer quotes above. The provider’s representative APR is the figure to focus on, not the lowest possible rate shown in an advert.
Our recommendation
Choose Zuto if you have fair-to-good credit and want to compare lenders before buying; choose Black Horse if you have strong credit and are already negotiating at a dealership. Moneybarn is reserved for borrowers with poor or limited credit who have checked the high total cost, while Oodle suits used-car buyers who value a quick soft-check application.
Once you understand the car finance maths, compare it with unsecured borrowing too: Monzo Loans: Instant Decisions, Highly Personalised Rates explains how personalised loan pricing can change the cost of funding a vehicle.